If I had known how delightful this series was going to be and how much I would enjoy it, then I would have jumped on it much earlier. Although weirdly enough, I am glad it took me this long to binge through the entire first three seasons — it took me about two weeks to power through all 26 episodes. I Binge-watched at least two episodes every evening for two weeks straight.
Ever since MAD MEN came to an end, I have been craving for another well-made, engaging throwback series set in the late ‘50s, early ‘60s, and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is precisely that show.
New York, New York, Baby! We get a heavy dosage of my beloved city, which is the principal setting for the series. Midge Maisel (Rachel Brosnahan) is an Upper West Side Manhattan housewife who stumbles into standup comedy by accident. Domestic life is not something she is excited about. Midge also seems ambivalent about motherhood, plus her husband has left her for his secretary. She has no choice but to pursue a living and become independent of her husband. Comedy was not a career you would seek out in the ’50s, but Mrs. Maisel pursues it against all the odds. And throughout the first three seasons, we get to see her honing and shaping her standup skills.
Hard to avoid the parallels with Joan Rivers and how Rivers began to make her mark in standup comedy in the 1950s. Even the way Rivers would dress on stage is almost identical. Perhaps Joan Rivers is a loose inspiration for Mrs. Maisel, but the similarities are definitely there.
The series leans pretty heavy on New York Jewish culture. They are depicting particular aspects of everyday life during that period. We see how much value and effort Midge puts into her appearance: She measures her body proportions every single day, tracking them religiously. The vanity aspect is a big part of the series. The effort women made to look good, even at home, striving to always look their best, like putting on makeup right before going to sleep. Midge works hard at her beauty, and her beautiful dresses are an extension of the character’s personality.
The casting is perfect. Midge’s business manager Susie (Alex Borstein), is excellent; her street-smart personality complements Midge nicely. Susie’s character development is equally as crucial as Mrs. Maisel’s. Although Susie is not as attractive as Midge and has a rougher personality still, Susie has to find ways to navigate similar issues and difficulties of being a woman in a male-dominated 1950s world.
Midge’s father, Abe Weissman (Tony Shaloub), is a complex character, just as compelling as Midge. The ensemble of supporting characters is fantastic: Rose Weissman (Marin Hinkle), Moishe Maisel (Kevin Pollak), and Shirley Maisel (Caroline Aaron) are all hilarious in every scene they appear together.
Luke Kirby, like Lenny Bruce, is phenomenal; I feel like he should have his own spin-off biopic and expand further on the legendary comic. Jane Lynch (Sophie Lennon) became one of my favorite characters, glad she became a regular as the series progressed. Midge’s husband, Joel Maisel (Michael Zegen), is pretty engaging enough that I kept finding myself rooting for him to make things work with Midge.
The writing is exceptional. I admire the distinct look and feel of the show; the colors and period sets are gorgeous. The garment district warehouse scenes are well executed. The particular showbiz aspect of the period is fascinating.
Rachel Brosnahan is now a star; her performance exudes charisma. I am sure Mrs. Maisel’s journey in the series will eventually lead her into the Johnny Carson show and possibly the infamous Johnny Carson couch.
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel cannot escape criticism for ignoring and pushing aside specific cultural issues of the period. Picking and choosing which battles to fight and showcase is totally the showrunners’ prerogative. However, the show is set during a crucial time in the history of the United States. A higher level of seriousness and sensitivity should be applied when dealing with real-life issues.
I realize that this type of show is now considered to be a “dramedy” style show; nonetheless, Mrs. Maisel has a unique opportunity here to tackle some crucial issues in upcoming seasons and remain as charming and entertaining as the first three seasons have been. While at the same time figuring out ways to be more grounded in reality.
The way season three unfolded and ended gave the writers and producers of this show a unique opportunity to highlight some of Midge’s obvious character flaws and address those flaws and her lack of sensitivity and urgency towards real-life issues in a more profound manner. Let us hope that is the route they decide to take.
Extremely excited for season four…
Five out of Five Popcorn Bags 🍿🍿🍿🍿🍿
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (Season 1,2 & 3). Streaming on Prime