It took me a couple of viewings to fully appreciate what James Gunn was trying to accomplish with Superman (2025). I really wanted to like this movie. But I wasn’t crazy about it the first time I saw it. And strangely enough, I enjoyed it considerably more the second time around.
But first, a little nostalgia. Christopher Reeve will always be Superman to me. That isn’t going to change. Not necessarily because he was the greatest interpretation of the character, but because he was my first superhero. I still remember the magic of watching Superman on the big screen in the 80s with my mother. There’s something about those childhood moviegoing experiences that stays with you long after the details of the films themselves begin to fade.
The first two Christopher Reeve films remain my absolute favorites. Richard Donner’s original Superman (1978) and Superman II (1980)l established a cinematic mythology that, for me, has never quite been surpassed. Even Superman III (1983), despite all the negative critical reception, it holds a special place in my memory. I remember having an absolute blast watching it in theaters as a kid. And yes, I even saw Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987) on the big screen. A deeply flawed movie, but the idea of cloning an evil version of Superman as his ultimate adversary was an interesting concept buried beneath all that questionable filmmaking.
Zack Snyder brought us a darker, more ambitious vision of Superman, anchored by Henry Cavill, who delivered a commanding portrayal of Superman. It was as a massive improvement over Bryan Singer’s Superman Returns (2006), which I did not enjoy—and I wasn’t a big fan of Brandon Routh’s interpretation of the Man of Steel.
Once I stopped expecting another Richard Donner, or Zack Snyder film, I could appreciate what Gunn was actually trying to accomplish. Gunn approaches Superman with much of the same creative energy he brought to Guardians of the Galaxy. There’s an enormous ensemble of eccentric characters, unexpected humor, and a relentless willingness to embrace the absurdity of comic book storytelling. He throws practically everything into the fire. And somehow, most of it works.
One decision I particularly appreciated was skipping the traditional origin story. We don’t need another two hours explaining Krypton’s destruction, the Kent family’s discovery of baby Kal-El, or Clark’s gradual realization that he’s different from everyone else. We’ve all been there several times. Instead, Gunn drops us into a world where Superman is already an established superhero, Lois Lane knows his secret identity, and the audience is expected to keep up. There’s surprisingly little Clark Kent here.
David Corenswet is terrific. His interpretation feels closer to the traditional comic book Superman than many recent cinematic versions. He’s kind, emotionally vulnerable, and almost stubbornly optimistic. He’s also remarkably easy to beat up. This version of Superman takes an extraordinary amount of punishment. He’s powerful, but far from invincible. Gunn seems particularly interested in reminding us that Superman’s greatest strength is his decency. Still, Corenswet takes third place behind Christopher Reeves, and Henry Cavill as my favorites.
I also enjoyed the clever modernization of Clark Kent’s disguise. His glasses apparently incorporate a form of hypnotic technology that prevents people from recognizing his resemblance to Superman. After decades of wondering how a pair of glasses could fool an entire city, somebody finally decided to address it.
Rachel Brosnahan is excellent as Lois Lane. In fact, she’s probably my favorite cinematic interpretation of the character since Margot Kidder. She’s intelligent, confident, confrontational, and never intimidated by Superman’s extraordinary abilities. Their relationship feels real, and their conversations carry some of the film’s strongest emotional moments.
Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor is another highlight. This version feels less like the traditional criminal mastermind and more like a modern technological billionaire whose enormous wealth has convinced him that he should be allowed to control everything around him. He’s arrogant, vindictive, and insecure. Luthor weaponizes public opinion, manipulating people’s fears and exploiting xenophobia to turn the world against Superman. He wants humanity to reject him. Even his approach to fight Superman feels like something out of a video game, developing thousands of calculated combat moves designed specifically to counter Superman’s abilities. It’s a fascinating interpretation of a villain whose greatest weapon has always been his intellect.
And underneath all the colorful comic book chaos, there’s a surprisingly relevant political dimension. Superman is repeatedly referred to as an alien, and a foreigner. Someone who doesn’t belong here. His intentions are questioned, his loyalty scrutinized, and his extraordinary abilities treated as a potential threat simply because he comes from somewhere else.
The immigrant allegory has always been part of Superman’s mythology, but Gunn brings it directly into the modern conversation. The traditional ideal of truth, justice, and the American way gives way to something more universal. This Superman isn’t particularly interested in defending one country’s interests. He wants to help people worldwide. Regardless of borders. Whether that makes him more relevant or less traditionally American will probably depend on who’s watching.
The supporting characters are a mixed bag, although several are genuinely entertaining.
Edi Gathegi (Mister Terrific) is easily one of the standouts. His technological gadgets, and dry personality make him an excellent addition to the DC Universe. Nathan Fillion (Guy Gardner / Green Lantern) is hilarious. Isabela Merced (Kendra Saunders / Hawkgirl) was another solid addition. Their action sequences are among the film’s most inventive. And then there’s Krypto. A flying superdog with a cape causing absolute mayhem. This CGI dog was a bold move. But it is exactly the kind of thing previous filmmakers might have avoided.
Jimmy Olsen (Skyler Gisondo) gets a fresh reinvention as an unlikely ladies’ man, including the hilarious subplot involving Lex Luthor’s girlfriend (Sara Sampaio). The Superman robots acting as the caretakers of the Fortress of Solitude was straight out of the comics from the 50s. Bradley Cooper as Jor-El was a strong addition. And the introduction of Kara Zor-El, as Supergirl (Emily Alcock). A hard-partying cosmic traveler who seems considerably less interested in responsibility than her famous cousin. Her quick cameo sets up the Supergirl movie.
There are moments when the movie feels less like a focused Superman adventure and more like Gunn trying to establish an entire cinematic universe. There is an enormous amount of mythology to introduce in a single film. Perhaps too much. The pacing can be frantic, and the humor occasionally undermines the dramatic tension. It’s also probably the corniest Superman movie ever made. Well, perhaps not quite as ridiculous as Superman IV. But it’s certainly close. The difference is that Gunn’s silliness feels intentional.
Ultimately, Superman is an entertaining, imaginative, and surprisingly uplifting comic book movie. It takes considerable risks, not all of which pay off, but there’s something refreshing about a filmmaker who refuses to treat these characters as though they’re embarrassed by their own mythology. James Gunn has delivered a bold, colorful, and occasionally ridiculous relaunch of the Superman franchise. He understands that Superman comes from a world of impossible science, bizarre villains, talking robots, and flying dogs. Rather than apologizing for that history, he embraces it. And I respect that.
SUPERMAN (2025). THREE OUT OF FIVE POPCORN BAGS 🍿🍿🍿

